If you’re still counting on a bidding war to push your home’s price sky-high, it’s time to hit the reset button. That chapter of the housing market is over.
From Frenzy to Reality
The numbers tell the story: today, about half of all homes on the market are selling below their asking price (Cotality).
At first glance, that may sound like bad news. But here’s the truth: it’s not. The overheated market of the past few years was never sustainable. What we’re seeing now is the market getting back to its natural rhythm.
Just take a look at Zillow’s data:
-
2018–2019 → Roughly 50–55% of homes sold under asking. Normal.
-
2021–2022 → Only about 25% did, thanks to record-low rates and frenzied demand.
-
2025 → We’re back to about 50%. A healthier, more balanced market.
So while it may feel like a letdown compared to recent years, this shift actually brings things back into line.
Why Sellers Need a New Playbook
The key takeaway? Your pricing strategy has never mattered more.
A few years ago, you could overprice your home and still walk away with multiple offers. Buyers had fewer choices and bigger budgets. That’s not the case anymore.
Today’s buyers are cautious, selective, and quick to move on from a listing that feels overpriced. And here’s the kicker: your first two weeks on the market are make-or-break. Miss the sweet spot, and your home risks going stale. Once that happens, buyers start wondering what’s wrong—and you’ll likely end up chasing the market with price cuts.
The Formula for Selling at (or Over) Asking
The good news? Homes are still selling at—or above—asking. In fact, half of them are. The difference comes down to strategy. Here’s how sellers are winning:
-
Prep Like a Pro – Knock out repairs, add fresh touches, and make your home shine before it hits the market. First impressions sell.
-
Price With Precision – Forget what’s listed down the street. Look at what’s actually sold—and let your agent guide you to a price that attracts serious buyers.
-
Stay Open to Negotiation – Flexibility is your friend. Maybe that means offering credit for repairs or covering part of closing costs. Remember, it doesn’t always have to be about lowering the price.
The Bottom Line
Half of today’s homes may be selling under asking—but yours doesn’t have to be one of them. With the right prep, pricing strategy, and a skilled local agent on your side, you can still capture top dollar.
The market has shifted. Expectations need to shift with it. But with the right approach in those crucial first weeks, your home can stand out—and sell for exactly what you want.