The Pricing Mistake That Could Cost You Your Sale
Most sellers enter the market with one number firmly in mind—their asking price. Unfortunately, that number is often the very thing that ends up costing them the most.
According to a recent Realtor.com survey, about 8 in 10 sellers (80%) expect to sell their home at or above asking price. But in reality, only about 4 in 10 (roughly 40%) actually do.
That’s a significant gap, and it’s where many sellers are caught off guard.
So why does this happen? And more importantly, how can you position yourself to be one of the sellers who gets top dollar?
Let’s take a closer look.
What Should You Really Expect for Your Home?
At first glance, that 40% may seem surprisingly low—but it’s actually much closer to normal than many people realize.
If you compare today’s market to 2019—the last truly “typical” housing market—what we’re seeing is simply a return to standard conditions. In fact, slightly more homeowners are still selling above list price today compared to 2019.
The reason it feels different is because the market from 2020 through mid-2022 was anything but normal.
During that time, buyer demand was extremely high, mortgage rates were low, and available inventory was at record lows. Homes were receiving multiple offers quickly, often selling well above asking price.
Today, the market has shifted.
There are more homes available, buyers have more choices, and they’re becoming much more selective about where they spend their money.
In other words, pricing your home like it’s still 2021 can quickly become a costly mistake.
What Happens When a Home Is Priced Too High?
Many sellers believe pricing high gives them room to negotiate. In reality, it often has the opposite effect.
When a home is priced above what buyers perceive as fair market value, most buyers don’t negotiate—they simply move on.
Price is often the first thing buyers notice. If your home doesn’t align with similar listings in your area, it may not even make it onto their showing list.
And once that happens, the domino effect begins:
- Higher price leads to less buyer interest
- Less interest means fewer showings and fewer offers
- Fewer offers result in more time sitting on the market
Homes that are priced at or just below market value tend to sell faster, while overpriced homes often linger. And the longer a home sits unsold, the harder it becomes to generate excitement around it.
The Price Cut Trap
When a listing sits too long without serious offers, many sellers resort to a price reduction.
In fact, Realtor.com reports that 16.7% of sellers are making price cuts today.
But here’s the challenge: a price reduction doesn’t always solve the problem.
In many cases, buyers interpret a price drop as a warning sign. They begin to wonder if something is wrong with the home—even when nothing is.
According to the National Association of Realtors (NAR), the longer a home stays on the market, the larger the price cut often needs to be in order to regain buyer attention.
What started as a strategy to “leave room for negotiation” can end up leading to a much lower final sale price.
Why Pricing Right from Day One Matters
Listing your home at—or slightly below—true market value may feel counterintuitive when your goal is to maximize profit.
But often, it’s the smartest strategy.
The goal isn’t simply to test the market and hope for the best. It’s to create strong demand from day one.
NAR describes this as finding the “Goldilocks” price—not too high, not too low, but just right.
Price too high, and buyers disappear.
Price too low, and buyers question the home’s value.
But price it correctly, and that’s where the real opportunity happens.
That’s also where having the right real estate agent becomes essential.
An experienced agent helps you understand:
- What buyers are actually paying right now
- How your home compares to others nearby
- How to price strategically to stand out immediately
In today’s market, that strategy can be the difference between:
Listing too high, watching your home sit, and eventually selling for less
—or—
Pricing correctly, creating competition, and maximizing your return from the start
Bottom Line
Many homeowners assume they can list high now and negotiate later—but that approach often backfires.
It’s one of the main reasons only 4 out of 10 sellers are actually getting their asking price or more.
If your goal is to be in that group, success starts with pricing your home correctly from day one.
Working with a knowledgeable local agent can help you avoid costly pricing mistakes—and position your home to sell faster and for the best possible price.